Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Bartholomew, Timothy V.

Publications and source records attributed to Bartholomew, Timothy V..

Component innovations for lower cost mechanical vapor compression

Despite significant capital and operating costs, mechanical vapor compression (MVC) remains the preferred technology for challenging brine concentration applications. Here, this work seeks to assess the dependence of MVC costs on feedwater salinity and desired water recovery and to quantify the value of improved component performance or reduced component costs for reducing the levelized cost of water (LCOW) of MVC. We built a cost optimization model coupling thermophysical, heat and mass transfer, and technoeconomic models to optimize and identify low cost MVC system designs as a function of feedwater salinity and water recovery. The LCOW ranges over 3.6 to 6.1 $\$$/m 3 for seawater feed salinities of 25–150 g/kg and water recoveries of 40–80 %. We then perform sensitivity analysis on parameter inputs to isolate irreducible costs and determine high value component innovation targets. The LCOW was most sensitive to evaporator material costs and performance, including the overall heat transfer coefficient in the evaporator. Process and material innovations such as polymer-composite evaporator tubes that reduce evaporator costs by 25 % without reducing heat transfer performance by more than 10 % would result in MVC cost reductions of 8 %.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Analysis of backwash settings to maximize net water production in an engineering-scale ultrafiltration system for water reuse

Ultrafiltration (UF) has been widely utilized as water pretreatment for different applications especially in water reuse. The UF system operation is characterized by a filtration phase, where particles accumulate on the membrane surface resulting in an increase in the transmembrane pressure (TMP) and a cleaning phase, where foulants are removed through cleaning cycles including physical backwash and chemical-enhanced backwash (CEB). In this study, data from an engineering-scale UF system treating reclaimed wastewater were used to assess the impact of backwashing on the filtration process. TMP backwash trigger, backwash duration, and CEB frequency were purposely varied for a cycle-by-cycle investigation on the net water production, water recovery, initial operating TMP, and filtration cycle duration. As the TMP backwash trigger was varied between 62 and 145kPa, the maximum net water production (63 m 3 /d) was achieved at 103kPa and water recovery remained relatively constant at approximately 92%. Backwash durations of 45, 65, and 85s were performed where both net water production and water recovery yielded similar results (~63 m 3 /d and ~ 91%) compared with 103kPa TMP backwash trigger. The CEB frequency was also lowered from one every three backwashes (1/3) to 1/6 and 1/12 and resulted in decreased net water production and water recovery while the initial TMP increased. Interestingly, the total number of CEBs remained approximately constant regardless of their frequency. In conclusion, results suggest that CEB is an important fouling control process to maximize water production.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Cost optimization of low-salt-rejection reverse osmosis

Low-salt-rejection reverse osmosis (LSRRO) is an emerging membrane-based desalination technology for concentrating brines with potentially lower energy consumption and cost than thermally driven processes. We assess the technoeconomic performance of LSRRO by using an optimization model that minimizes the levelized cost of water (LCOW). We develop detailed models for the RO module and other equipment using WaterTAP (Water treatment Technoeconomic Assessment Platform), an open-source simulation and optimization software for water treatment. We improve upon previous LSRRO cost optimization studies by optimizing the salt permeability for each stage, which has significant implications for technoeconomic performance. We present the cost-optimal design, operation, and performance for three cases: 35 g/L TDS feed at 70% recovery, 70 g/L at 55%, and 125 g/L at 35%. The cost-optimal LCOW and specific energy consumption (SEC) for these cases are 0.70, 1.89, and 7.41 $/m 3 and 3.9, 8.4, and 30.4 kWh/m 3 , respectively. For each case, we use sensitivity analyses to provide guidance on key factors that impact economic viability. We also present the cost-optimal LCOW and SEC for feed concentrations between 5 and 220 g/L TDS and recoveries between 30 and 90%. So, we compare LSRRO to other high-salinity desalination technologies and find that it may be cost-competitive below feed concentrations of 125 g/L.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

High-impact innovations for high-salinity membrane desalination

Significance Researchers lack the tools for quantitatively evaluating the impact of their research on technology costs, especially when those technologies comprise multiple components or when the component costs are highly uncertain. We propose a suite of tools to aid in evaluating technology platforms, setting system- and component-level research targets and identifying high-impact innovation trajectories. These tools are applicable to any technology composed of multiple components whose performance or cost will benefit from innovation, but they are especially valuable for membrane systems in which the high interdependence in components amplifies or dampens the effects of innovation in nonintuitive ways.

Dudchenko, Alexander V.↗

Cost optimization of high recovery single stage gap membrane distillation

Estimating the cost of membrane distillation (MD) processes at scale is confounded by the vast array of possible process configurations, module configurations, and operating conditions and the extreme sensitivity of MD costs to these parameters. This work develops a comprehensive MD cost optimization framework for minimizing the levelized cost of water (LCOW) as a function of feed salinity and temperature. Our single stage gap MD model fully captures solution properties, heat transfer, and mass transfer relationships in the modules to determine the cost optimal design as a function of multiple decision variables, including process configuration (feed location and connectivity between the hot and cold-side), the gap type (air, permeate, conductive), equipment sizes (membrane, heater, chiller, and heat exchanger units), and operating conditions (flow rates, hot and cold side temperatures, and heating and cooling duties). We estimate that the minimum LCOW of conductive gap MD ranges between $\$$10 and $\$$16 per m 3 for feed salinities of 25 g/L to 200 g/L and water recoveries of 30%–75%. Further, we update several heuristic assumptions for cost optimal system operation, including: increased thermal conductivity of the gap decreases system costs; cost optimal MD operates at the highest allowable temperature; and the LCOW is a strong function of brine salinity. Finally, we find that improving membrane properties and lowering heating and cooling costs will provide only modest reductions in costs (<25%).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Computational framework for modeling membrane processes without process and solution property simplifications

Accurately modeling membrane processes is critical to evaluating novel process configurations, designing scalable membrane systems, informing process cost estimates, and directing future research. Most membrane process models trade accuracy for computational efficiency by employing simplified approximations of the process (i.e. no salt flux, no pressure drop) and solution properties (i.e. ideal solution, and constant density, viscosity, and diffusivity). Our report introduces a detailed one-dimensional finite difference model for evaluating membrane processes that avoids these common simplifications. We apply this model to quantify the error introduced by these simplifications for case studies of reverse osmosis, osmotically assisted reverse osmosis, forward osmosis, and pressure retarded osmosis. While the magnitude of error introduced by these simplifications is reliant on the case study parameters and specifications, we find that existing model formulations can underestimate or overestimate average water flux by nearly 50% for some membrane processes operating under standard conditions. Lastly we investigate the error introduced by simplified inlet-outlet models that do not solve the governing system of differential equations, and we assess the accuracy of novel inlet-outlet formulations that use a log and geometric mean, instead of the typical arithmetic mean, to represent non-linear water flux profiles.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Cost Optimization of Osmotically Assisted Reverse Osmosis

We develop a nonlinear optimization model to identify minimum cost designs for osmotically assisted reverse osmosis (OARO), a multistaged membrane-based process for desalinating high-salinity brines. The optimization model enables comprehensive evaluation of a complex process configuration and operational decision space that includes nonlinear process performance and implicit relationships among membrane stages, saline sweep cycles, and makeup, purge, and recycle streams. Here, the objective function minimizes cost, rather than energy or capital expenditures, to accurately account for the trade-offs in capital and operational expenses inherent in multistaged membrane processes. Generally, we find that cost-optimal OARO processes minimize the number of stages, eliminate the use of saline makeup streams, purge from the first sweep cycle, and successively decrease stage membrane area and sweep flow rates. The optimal OARO configuration for treating feed salinities of 50–125 g/L total dissolved solids with water recoveries between 30–70% results in costs less than or equal to $6 per m3 of product water. Sensitivity analysis suggests that future research to minimize OARO costs should focus on minimizing the membrane structural parameter while maximizing the membrane burst pressure and reducing the membrane unit cost.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Management and dewatering of brines extracted from geologic carbon storage sites

Subsurface pressure management is a significant challenge in geologic CO 2 storage. Elevated pressure generated from the injection of supercritical CO 2 can be managed by the withdrawal of brine from saline formations before or during CO 2 injection; however, management of the extracted brines is non-trivial because they may have high concentrations of dissolved solids and other contaminants. Dewatering a brine can reduce the volume needing disposal; in addition, water separated from the brine can be a source of usable low salinity water. This review will summarize the composition of brines extracted from select domestic geologic CO 2 storage sites, will calculate the minimum of work of dewatering, and will provide a critical review of developed and developing desalination/dewatering technologies that could be applied to brines extracted from saline formations before or during geologic CO 2 storage operations. Herein are also highlighted, when appropriate, the similarities and the differences between dewatering brines produced from oil/gas operations and brines extracted from geologic CO 2 storage. Since a source of steam or natural gas is likely unavailable/unsuitable for dewatering brines extracted during CO 2 storage, the ideal treatment processes should have a high electrical efficiency and, if possible, should be able to take advantage of the inherent elevated temperature of these brines.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Osmotically assisted reverse osmosis for high salinity brine treatment

Here, this work evaluates a novel osmotically assisted reverse osmosis (OARO) process for dewatering high salinity brines using readily available membranes and equipment. While traditional reverse osmosis processes are limited to treating brines with osmotic pressures below the membrane burst pressure, in OARO, the osmotic pressure difference across a membrane is reduced with a permeate side saline sweep. A series of OARO stages can be used to sequentially reduce the concentration of the feed until a traditional RO process can obtain fully desalinated water. This paper develops an OARO model to identify feasible operating conditions for this process and to estimate the water recovery and energy consumption across a range of brine feed concentrations. For a feed of 100–140 g/L sodium chloride, we estimate that the OARO process is capable of a 35–50% water recovery with an energy consumption of 6–19 kWh per m 3 of product water. Finally, the results suggest that an OARO dewatering process improves upon the recovery of reverse osmosis for high salinity brines and has a comparable or lower energy consumption than mechanical vapor compression.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗